Category: Civil

Perry, Lunine to Co-Chair NRC Human Spaceflight Study Committee

Perry, Lunine to Co-Chair NRC Human Spaceflight Study Committee

Former Secretary of Defense Bill Perry and space scientist Jonathan Lunine will co-chair the National Research Council’s new study on the future of the human spaceflight program.

Perry currently is a professor at Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Cooperation.  Lunine is a professor at Cornell University and Director of its Center for Radiophysics and Space Research.

The study was requested by Congress in the 2010 NASA Authorization Act, which directed NASA to contract with the NRC in FY2012 (which ended last month).   The study officially got under way in August, but the co-chairs were named just today; other committee members have not been announced yet.   NRC officials have previously indicated that the study would take about 22 months to complete.

According to its Statement of Task, the committee will “provide findings, rationale, prioritized recommendations, and decision rules that could enable and guide future planning for U.S. human space exploration” for the FY2014-FY2023 time period “while considering the program’s likely evolution in 2015-2030.”

Perry was Secretary of Defense from 1994-1997 after other stints at DOD — including under secretary of defense for research and engineering — and a long business career in high-tech companies.    HIs doctorate is in mathematics and he is a member of the National Academy of Engineering.

Lunine is a highly respected space scientist whose work spans planetary science, theoretical astrophysics and astrobiology.  He is involved in planetary exploration missions like Cassini-Huygens and Juno, and is also a member of the science team for the James Webb Space Telescope.  He is a member of the National Academy of Sciences.

The pairing of two individuals from the often disparate fields of science and engineering parallels NASA’s current effort through the Mars Program Planning Group to develop a Mars exploration strategy that responds both to the agency’s science goals and the President’s directive to send humans to orbit Mars in the 2030s.  NASA’s science programs are closely tied to priorities identified by NRC “decadal surveys” conducted about every 10 years (a decade) for the next 10 years of research.   Lunine was a member of the steering committee for the most recent (2010) decadal survey for astronomy and astrophysics.

Correction:  The spelling of Dr. Lunine’s first name in the first sentence has been corrected, adding the “t” in Jonathan.

Events of Interest: Week of October 14-20, 2012 – UPDATE

Events of Interest: Week of October 14-20, 2012 – UPDATE

UPDATE:   This is Earth Science Week and information about related events has been added in the “During the Week” section.

The following events may be of interest in the week ahead.   Congress remains in recess (except for pro forma sessions) until after the elections.

During the Week

October 14-20 is Earth Science Week, an annual celebration established in 1998 by the American Geophysical Union to help children, students and the general public understand how geoscientists collection information about the planet, according a NASA website.  NASA is planning a number of Internet-based events as well as a Univisión radio interview in Spanish on Tuesday with scientists Erika Podest and Miguel Romain.   The list of NASA-sponsored events is on our calender.  This year NASA is reaching out to the Spanish-speaking community not only with Tuesday’s radio interview on Univisión, but a dedicated section of its Earth Science Week website in Spanish.

Sunday-Friday, October 14-19

  • DPS 2012 (Division on Planetary Science of the American Astronomical Society), Reno, NV

Monday-Thursday, October 15-18

Tuesday, October 16

Wednesday-Thursday, October 17-18

  • ISPCS 2012 (International Symposium for Personal and Commercial Spaceflight), Las Cruces, NM

Thursday, October 18

 

Privately Funded Asteroid Mission Passes Initial Soundness Review

Privately Funded Asteroid Mission Passes Initial Soundness Review

The B612 Foundation announced on Thursday that its Sentinel Special Review Team (SSRT) gave a thumbs up on the technical soundness of the Foundation’s implementation plans and mission design for its Sentinel asteroid hunting mission.   The Foundation, led by former astronauts Ed Lu and Rusty Schweickart, has a Space Act Agreement with NASA to further the goal of launching a privately funded spacecraft to identify and catalog asteroids that could pose a threat to Earth.

The Ball Aerospace-built infrared (IR) space telescope would be placed into a “Venus-trailing” orbit by a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket in 2017 under current plans.  The project is sometimes described as a “commercial” space science mission, but it is more accurate to call it a philanthropic activity.   The Foundation plans to make all the data publicly available, not to sell it or otherwise try to recoup its costs.

In an interview, Lu described the project as being similar to ground-based telescopes such as the Keck telescopes in Hawai and the Allen radio telescope array that were built with money from individuals interested in advancing knowledge.    He said typically philanthropic projects of this magnitude obtain about 50 percent of their funding from a top tier of one, two or three donors, another 30 percent from a second tier of a couple of hundred donors, and the remaining 20 percent from a very large number of smaller donors.  He said most donors to such projects are not motivated by the idea of an “edifice” being erected as a legacy, but by a desire to “give back” and “make a difference.”

An advantage of a project like Sentinel, he adds, is that it is “addressing a problem that will fix a problem” rather than some more nebulous goal.  The problem to be solved is cataloging a larger number of asteroids that could pose a threat to the planet than can be observed using ground-based telescopes. 

The Foundation released the names of the individuals who comprise the SSRT — a veritable who’s who of experts in buiding and managing robotic space programs — chosen by the Foundation or appointed by NASA.    NASA is working with the Foundation through a Space Act Agreement signed in May under which NASA will provide technical advice and use of the Deep Space Network (DSN) to communicate with Sentinel during its 6.5 year mission.  NASA has its own asteroid cataloging activity, but it is limited to ground-based instruments.  The likelihood that the agency will be provided with adequate resources to build and launch its own dedicated asteroid-hunting space telescope is deemed to be very small, hence the Foundation’s efforts to fund the mission privately.

The 11-member SSRT is led by Tom Gavin, former Director of Flight Projects and Mission Success at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), which builds and operates many of NASA’s deep space probes.   Other members include Steve Battel of Battel Engineering, an expert on progam management and systems engineering who just completed six years as a member of the National Academies Space Studies Board; John Casani, who managed the Voyager, Galileo and Cassini missions at JPL and led the independent review of the James Webb Space Telescope program in 2010; and Orlando Figueroa, who retired from NASA after serving as Director of NASA’s Mars Program and who just led a team that outlined options for reconfiguring the Mars exploration program in the wake of budget cuts and a desire to make the program responsive both to the agency’s science and human exploration goals.

The SSRT completed its first “Program Concept and Implementation Review” in September and found that the “implementation plans and mission design, as put forward by the B612 Foundation and its partner Ball Aerospace, are technically sound and will lead to a successful Sentinel mission.” 

The task of the Sentinel project is to catalog asteroids that could threaten Earth, but the B612 Foundation’s goal is much bigger — “to protect the future of humanity on Earth while opening up the solar system.”   Lu and Schweickart have been leaders of the Association of Space Explorers (ASE) effort to promote international planning for how to deflect any asteroids that might have Earth in its sights.  Lu is co-inventor of the “gravity-tractor” concept to alter an asteroid’s trajectory so it would avoid Earth.

 

Two Rocket Engine Anomalies Under Review

Two Rocket Engine Anomalies Under Review

The Air Force has begun an investigation into the Delta IV second stage anomaly on October 4 just as SpaceX and NASA are beginning a completely separate look at why one of the nine engines on SpaceX’s Falcon 9 failed on October 7.

U.S. space launches have been so reliable recently that having two anomalies occur just days apart seems unusual, although that is not to suggest there is any common cause.

The Delta IV put the GPS II-F3 satellite into its correct orbit, but the United Launch Alliance (ULA) said that it “observed an unexpected data signature” signalling reduced thrust from the RL10 second stage engine.  The Air Force and ULA are waiting to better understand the problem before their next launch.   That mission, the Air Force’s X-37B Orbital Test Vehicle (OTV), was scheduled for liftoff on October 25 on an Atlas V.  Atlas V uses a different version of the RL10 engine, but ULA said it would not certify the rocket ready for launch until it understands what happened on the Delta IV.  ULA builds and launches both rockets.

Air Force Space Command Commander Gen. William Shelton set up an Accident Investigation Board (AIB) yesterday, saying “the time honored rigor and earnest process of an AIB will serve us well as we attempt to determine the root cause of this anomaly.”

Meanwhile, SpaceX announced today that a joint “CRS-1 Post-Flight Investigation Board” has been established with NASA to “methodically analyze all data in an effort to understand what occurred to engine 1” during Sunday’s launch of the Dragon spacecraft to the International Space Station (ISS).  Engine 1 failed during ascent.  The other eight engines on the Falcon 9 compensated and Dragon was delivered into its correct orbit, but a secondary payload, ORBCOMM OG2, was not and subsequently reentered.  This was the first Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) mission for SpaceX, and Dragon is now snugly berthed with the ISS.

SpaceX and NASA had been planning for the next SpaceX CRS mission in January.   It is not clear at this point if that launch date will hold. SpaceX is under contract to NASA to launch 12 CRS missions to the ISS between now and 2015.

New Government Travel Restrictions Force AAS to Cancel November Conference

New Government Travel Restrictions Force AAS to Cancel November Conference

The American Astronautical Society (AAS) announced today that it must cancel its annual National Conference in November because new travel restrictions for government employees caused all of the high level NASA officials who were scheduled to speak at the conference to withdraw.  The decision does not affect next week’s AAS Von Braun symposium in Huntsville, AL, which will proceed as scheduled.

AAS President Frank Slazer said in a letter circulated by AAS that the society is not alone in suffering from the absence of government speakers and attendees at its conferences:  “a recent American Meteorological Society conference lost 100 out of 130 NOAA attendees at very short notice,” he wrote.   An AAS conference this summer on International Space Station research also had lower than expected government attendance because of the travel restrictions, he noted.

The November conference was scheduled for November 28-29, 2012 in Pasadena, CA in partnership with the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) and The Planetary Society. 

“Without key NASA and other government speakers and participants, [AAS] leadership made the painful decision to cancel this conference rather than risk the quality of event that we have consistently worked to provide our membership and attendees,” Slazer explained.

The AAS Wernher von Braun Memorial Symposium scheduled for next week in Huntsville, AL, however, is proceeding as scheduled.

Editor’s note:   In the interest of full disclosure, I am Vice President-Public Policy of AAS.   That is not why I make this comment, however.  It is absolutely true that taxpayers’ dollars should not be squandered on unnecessary or exorbitant travel, but meetings of professional societies like AAS provide an opportunity for the public — those very same taxpayers — to learn about what their tax dollars are enabling, and places for the science and engineering communities to interact, leading to better science and engineering.   These new rules are the result of a single agency, the General Services Administration, losing control of its conference planning process, but everyone is being made to suffer.   One can only hope that a more reasonable set of policies that deal with the actual problem will be put in place in the near future.   The Pasadena conference was really going to be terrific — and I say that as a space policy analyst, not an AAS official.  What a shame.

Dragon Berths with ISS on First Operational Commercial Cargo Mission

Dragon Berths with ISS on First Operational Commercial Cargo Mission

SpaceX’s Dragon spacecraft successfully berthed with the International Space Station (ISS) this morning.   ISS Commander and NASA astronaut Suni Williams “installed” Dragon onto its docking port on the Harmony module using Canadarm2 at 9:03 am ET.   Japanese astronaut Aki Hoshide had used Canadarm2 to grapple Dragon at 6:56 am ET.

Dragon was launched on a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket on Sunday.

The hatch between Dragon and ISS is scheduled to open about 6:00 am ET tomorrow following efforts today to pressurize the vestibule between the two and install data and power cables.  Dragon will remain attached to ISS for 18 days while the ISS crew unloads 882 pounds of supplies, science experiments and hardware and then reload it with 1,673 pounds of cargo for return to Earth.  Unberthing and reentry is scheduled for October 28.

This is the first operational commercial cargo mission to the ISS, following SpaceX’s successful test mission in May.

Sarah Brightman to Be Next Space Tourist

Sarah Brightman to Be Next Space Tourist

Confirming rumors that have been swirling for some time, English recording artist Sarah Brightman was officially introduced at a Moscow press conference today as the next “spaceflight participant” to visit the International Space Station (ISS).

Russia has launched several such “space tourists” to the ISS since Dennis Tito was first in 2001, but those flights have been suspended while NASA needs Soyuz seats to take U.S. and other non-Russian ISS crews members to and from ISS.  Each Soyuz can accommodate only three people.   NASA pays Russia about $56 million “per seat” today (which will increase to about $63 million in 2014) which includes transportation up and back and training.  Prices for space tourists are rumored to be the $20-25 million range according to press reports over the years, but the actual price is a closely held secret.   How much Brightman is paying was asked at the press conference, but Eric Anderson, Chairman of Space Adventures, said it was “confidential.” 

Space Adventures is the U.S.-based company that arranges many of these space tourism flights.  It posted a video of the Moscow press conference on YouTube, though it is as much glitzy advertisement as news event.   Brightman begins her statement by going on about upcoming recordings and concerts during 2013 before she begins six months of more intensive spaceflight training.   Born in 1960, she says the TV images of Neil Armstrong stepping out on the Moon in 1969 opened her mind to the possibility of journeying into space herself.

Brightman says that details on exactly when the mission will take place will be announced soon after consultation with the other ISS partners, but it is widely expected in 2015.  The decision by Russia and the other ISS partners to keep two ISS crewmembers in space for a one-year mission beginning in 2015 is rumored to have been influenced by Russia’s desire to resume space tourism flights and Brightman’s in particular.  Keeping two crewmembers aboard ISS through a regular crew rotation will open up those Soyuz seats for other passengers.

Brightman said she wants to tie her spaceflight to her work with the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), for which she is an “Artist for Peace.”   A UNESCO representative who spoke at the press conference heralded her flight’s potential to advance UNESCO’s goals.

Calling herself not a dreamer, but a dream chaser, Brightman said she hopes to encourage others to take inspiration from her journey “both to chase down their own dreams and help fulfill important global objectives.”  “Dreamchaser” is the title of a new album she will release next year and has become the theme of her space mission.  Brightman has set up a website for fans to follow her training and the mission.

Search and Rescue Satellite Program Celebrates 30 Years, 30,000 Rescues

Search and Rescue Satellite Program Celebrates 30 Years, 30,000 Rescues

It may be getting a lot of advice these days about how to manage its satellite programs, but the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is also getting a pat on the back for 30 years of helping rescue people in distress through management of the U.S. portion of the international Cospas-SARSAT search and rescue satellite system.  More than 30,000 people around the world have been rescued because of this program.

Cospas-SARSAT started as a cooperative effort among the Soviet Union, the United States, Canada and France.  Transponders that could detect distress signals from Emergency Locator Transmitters on ships and aircraft, and later carried by individuals, were placed on Soviet (now Russian) navigation satellites and American polar-orbiting weather satellites.  Today, the number of countries and organizations that participate in operation and management of the program has grown to 43.

The first U.S. rescue was 30 years ago today when the Coast Guard pulled three people from a sinking catamaran 300 miles off the coast of New England after being alerted through the Cospas-SARSAT system.  Of the approximately 30,000 people rescued since then, about 7,000 were in the United States, including 198 this year alone.

 

 

Third Report in Three Weeks Critiques NOAA Satellite Management

Third Report in Three Weeks Critiques NOAA Satellite Management

UPDATE:   The final SATTF report was released in December 2012.

ORIGINAL STORY, October 10, 2012:  The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is inviting public comment on the draft report of the Satellite Task Force (SATTF) established by the NOAA Science Advisory Board (SAB) last year.  This is the third report in three weeks critiquing how NOAA manages and executes its satellite programs.

SATTF was created by NOAA’s SAB in September 2011 and chaired by Robert Winokur.  Winokur is Deputy and Technical Director, Oceanography, Space and Maritime Domain Awareness, in the office of the Chief of Naval Operations; he also is currently the Acting Oceanographer of the Navy.  The task force was created to provide advice to the SAB “to recommend a way forward for NOAA’s satellite program, starting with initial NESDIS recommendations and seeking a more affordable, flexible and robust satellite and services architecture….”    NESDIS is NOAA’s Satellite and Information Service, which manages NOAA’s satellite programs.  NOAA is part of the Department of Commerce.

The report offers a lengthy list of findings and observations that begin with the usual concerns about budgets.  It concludes, for example, that “NOAA’s budget for currently planned space systems appears to be unsustainable.”  The report goes on to call attention to the need for an integrated approach to NOAA’s satellite programs, recommending that NOAA create a “Chief Systems Engineering function within NESDIS,” and develop an “integrated master schedule.”  In particular, it tells NOAA that it needs an “integrated and comprehensive systems engineering approach … within NESDIS to transition from the current segment-centric engineering approach” to an integrated approach.

The SATTF wants NOAA to look at options for a future distributed systems architecture instead of today’s consolidated architecture.  As an example, NOAA’s geostationary weather satellite system today relies on two operational multi-sensor GOES satellites in the East and West positions.   Instead, NOAA should consider single instruments on a larger number of separate satellites (perhaps as hosted payloads). the SATTF suggests.  The Department of Defense’s Operationally Responsive Space (ORS) effort is offered as a model for “rapid response, lower capability alternatives.” 

This is the third report in three weeks criticizing NOAA’s execution of its satellite programs.   An Independent Review Team (IRT) headed by Tom Young that looked at how NOAA and its parent, the Department of Commerce, oversee the management of satellite programs was released on September 21.  It called the system “dysfunctional.”  A week later, the Inspector General (IG) of the Department of Commerce issued a report focused just on NOAA’s polar orbiting weather satellites.  It warns of a potential 10-16 month data gap before the first Joint Polar Satellite System (JPSS-1) satellite is operational and makes nine recommendations on how to ensure the JPSS program succeeds. 

The SATTF draft report posted today is open for public comment until November 9, 2012.   Instructions on how to comment are available on the NOAA SAB website

JAXA Celebrates 20 Years of U.S.-Japan Human Spaceflight Cooperation

JAXA Celebrates 20 Years of U.S.-Japan Human Spaceflight Cooperation

As part of its celebration of 20 years of U.S.-Japanese human spaceflight cooperation, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) will hold three events in Washington, DC this month.  Registration is requested by tomorrow, October 10.

The three events will be held at the Japan Information and Culture Center (JICC), 1150 18th Street, NW, Suite 100, Washington DC.  They focus on films (in Japanese with English subtitles) about JAXA’s successful HAYABUSA mission that returned samples of an asteroid to Earth.  The October 24 event also features “Space Talk” with JAXA astronaut Norishigi Kanai and NASA astronaut Leland Melvin (currently NASA’s Associate Administrator for Education).   Each event will be followed by a reception.

The events are:

  • October 18, 6:30-8:30 pm ET — Welcome Home, HAYABUSA (film by SHOCHIKU Co.)
  • October 24
    • 5:00-5:45 pm ET — Space Talk with JAXA astronaut Norishigi Kani and NASA astronaut Leland Melvin
    • 6:00-8:30 pm pm ET — HAYABUSA: The Long Return Home (film by TOEI Company, Ltd)
  • October 29, 6:00-8:30 pm ET — HAYABUSA (film by 20th Century Fox Japan)

Registration information is available in our calendar entry here.  Seating is limited, so early registration is required.