Category: International

Events of Interest: Week of October 22-26, 2012–UPDATE

Events of Interest: Week of October 22-26, 2012–UPDATE

UPDATE:   This update highlights the Solar System Exploration @ 50 events taking place this week in the “During the Week” section.

The following events may of interest in the coming week.  Congress continues to be in recess (except for pro forma sessions) until after the elections.

During the Week

Among the interesting activities this week, three new crew members will launch to the International Space Station (ISS) on Tuesday.  They will join the three astronauts already there and return the ISS crew complement to six (three Russians, two Americans, and one Japanese).  NASA TV coverage of the 6:51 am ET launch will begin at 5:30 am ET.  NASA astronaut Kevin Ford and Russian cosmonauts Oleg Novitsky and Evgeny Tarelkin will dock with the ISS two days later (October 25) at 8:35 am ET.   The following day, October 26, NASA will hold a press conference to discuss an upcoming contingency spacewalk to fix an ammonia leak on one of the ISS radiators.   NASA astronaut and ISS commander Suni Williams and Japanese astronaut Aki Hoshide will conduct the spacewalk on November 1.  The sixth ISS crew member is Russian cosmonaut Yuri Malenchenko.

Also this week, NASA and the National Geographic are holding events to celebrate 50 years of planetary exploration — Solar System Exploration @ 50.   In 1962, NASA launched its first two planetary probes — Mariner 1 and Mariner 2.  Mariner 1 was lost in a launch accident, but Mariner 2 flew by Venus in December of that year, setting the stage for 50 years of discoveries (so far) by U.S. robotic probes.  A panel discussion sponsored by the National Geographic at its offices in Washington, DC on Wednesday night, and a 2-day NASA History Office-sponsored conference all day Thursday and Friday at the Lockheed Martin Global Vision Center in Arlington, Virginia, will discuss not only what we’ve learned over the past 50 years and plans for the future, but how decisions are made on which missions to launch, international cooperation, the Soviet/Russian planetary program, and public perceptions.  Click on the links to the events below for registration information.

Monday, October 22

Tuesday, October 23

 Wednesday, October 24

Thursday-Friday, October 25-26

Friday, October 26

NASA to Celebrate Shuttle's End Four Days Before Elections, Republicans Step Up Criticism

NASA to Celebrate Shuttle's End Four Days Before Elections, Republicans Step Up Criticism

NASA will celebrate the end of the space shuttle program on November 2 by moving the Atlantis orbiter to its permanent exhibition site.  The event, just four days before the elections, could give Republican candidates an opening to sharpen their recent attacks on the Obama Administration for making the United States dependent on Russia to transport astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS).

Republican Vice Presidential Candidate Paul Ryan and Florida Republican Senatorial candidate Rep. Connie Mack stepped up criticism of President Obama’s space policy this week.  A major focus of their comments was U.S. dependency on Russia for crew access to the ISS.  While they failed to mention that it was President George W. Bush who first decided that a multi-year “gap” in U.S. human space access was acceptable, it is accurate that President Obama chose to retain that part of the Bush space policy and the shuttle program ended on his watch.   How many voters will recall — or care — that it was a Bush policy first remains to be seen.

Florida is a key state in determining who wins the Presidency.  Recent polls show Republican candidate Mitt Romney with a lead over President Obama.  As for the contest between incumbent Senator Bill Nelson (D) and Mack, Nelson appears to have the advantage at the moment.

Under President Bush’s space policy, a new system, Constellation, was to be in place by 2014 using the Ares I rocket and Orion spacecraft.  He wanted the shuttle program ended in 2010, meaning a gap of four years.  Shortly after his inauguration in 2009, however, President Obama ordered a review of the Constellation program by a committee chaired by Norman Augustine.  It concluded that Ares 1/Orion actually would not be ready until 2017 at the earliest, so the gap might have been at least seven years. 

How long the gap actually will be is unknown.  The shuttle program flew its last mission in 2011 rather than 2010.   President Obama initiated the “commercial crew” program to encourage private sector companies to build their own systems to take astronauts to and from the ISS.   NASA anticipates that such a capability will be ready in 2017, though some of the companies say it could be as early as 2015.  That would mean a gap of four-to-six years, but since none of the commercial crew systems has flown yet, it is anyone’s guess as to when the United States once again will be able to launch people into orbit.

It seems odd that NASA would choose to remind everyone so close to the election about the current state of the human spaceflight program.  Regardless of whether one faults Bush or Obama — or both — NASA must rely on Russia indefinitely for crew access to a space station that cost U.S. taxpayers $60-100 billion depending on how the costs are counted.   Nonetheless, on November 2, a final celebration of the space shuttle program will take place as Atlantis is moved from Kennedy Space Center’s (KSC’s) Vehicle Assembly Building to the KSC Visitor Complex beginning about 7:00 am ET.  A ceremony featuring NASA Administrator Charlie Bolden, KSC Director and former shuttle astronaut Bob Cabana, and other astronauts and officials is scheduled for 9:45 am ET.  Atlantis, which flew the final space shuttle mission, STS-135, in 2011 is the last of the shuttle orbiters to be moved to exhibition sites.

The event could provide an opportunity for NASA to highlight President Obama’s goals for the human spaceflight program — utilizing the International Space Station through 2020 using commercial crew and commercial cargo systems followed by sending astronauts to visit an asteroid by 2025 and, separately, to orbit Mars in the 2030s.  It could also, however, give Republican politicians a bully pulpit to criticize those plans as Ryan and Mack did in recent days.

According to The Hill newspaper, on Wednesday Ryan criticized the Obama Administration for undoing the Bush plan and “[n]ow we have effectively no plan.  We are not putting people into space anymore.”   Yesterday, Mack called for a “bold” space program according to the Orlando Sentinel.   Neither he nor Ryan offered any specifics on how the space program would change under a Romney-Ryan administration, though.  The  Romney-Ryan campaign has said only that NASA does not need more money, but clearer priorities, and that, if elected, Romney would establish a group of people to advise him on what to do.

Mack’s congressional district is near Ft. Myer on Florida’s Gulf Coast — far from Kennedy Space Center and the Space Coast.  He has not been very involved in space program issues so far and does not seem particularly conversant in them.  For example, the Orlando Sentinel quotes him as saying:  “‘The idea that Russia and China are responsible for manned space launches for us is not right.”    China does not conduct any launches for the United States, of course.  In fact, NASA is prohibited by law from cooperating with China pursuant to language included in NASA appropriations bills by Mack’s fellow Republican Congressman Frank Wolf (R-VA).    Mack is, however, a co-sponsor of the Space Leadership Act (H.R. 6491) introduced by Wolf and others last month.

Some space advocates rue the fact that space policy is not a significant issue in this election.  Many had expected that space would figure more prominently at least in Florida.  With NASA providing such a prime opportunity to focus on the space program four days before the election, they may get their wish.

ESA Chooses Cheops as Next Exoplanet Hunter

ESA Chooses Cheops as Next Exoplanet Hunter

The European Space Agency (ESA) announced today that the CHaracterizing ExOPlanets Satellite (Cheops) will be the first small satellite in ESA’s Science Programme.  The announcement comes just two days after European astronomers revealed they had discovered an exoplanet orbiting Alpha Centauri, the nearest star to our Sun, using a ground-based telescope.

Scheduled for launch in 2017, Cheops will join other ground- and space-based instruments searching for and studying planets orbiting other stars in the universe — exoplanets.  In particular it will be looking for “super-Earths,” planets more massive than Earth up to the size of Neptune.   The project is a partnership between ESA and Switzerland.  The satellite will be placed into an 800-kilometer sun-synchronous Earth orbit.

Cheops will look for planets using the transit approach where it will detect the dimming of a star as a planet passes in front of it.  It will focus on nearby bright stars already known to have planets and measure the radius of those planets.  If a planet’s mass is known, its density then can be calculated thereby revealing other characteristics.

The small satellite category of ESA space science missions is new and attracted 26 proposals when it was announced last spring.  The satellites are supposed to be low cost and developed quickly.  ESA refers to this as a “possible new class” of ESA missions suggesting that its success or failure in meeting those criteria could determine the future of the category.

The astrophysics community is quite excited about exoplanets these days.  Data from NASA’s Kepler space telescope has confirmed the existence of 77 planets around other stars in our galaxy, with another 2,321 candidates for which additional data is required before confirmation.  The European discovery regarding Alpha Centauri earlier this week was made using a telescope at the European Southern Observatory in Chile.

Spacewalk Needed to Repair Ammonia Leak-Press Conference Oct. 26 — Corrected

Spacewalk Needed to Repair Ammonia Leak-Press Conference Oct. 26 — Corrected

CORRECTION:  The press conference is next Friday, October 26, not today.  

An ammonia leak on one of the International Space Station’s (ISS’s) radiators means that NASA astronaut and ISS commander Suni Williams and Japanese astronaut Aki Hoshide will be taking another spacewalk very soon.   NASA will hold a news conference at 1:00 pm CT (2:00 pm ET) on Friday, October 26, to discuss those plans.

The spacewalk is scheduled for November 1.

India Wins Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court

India Wins Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court

The National Law School of India University in Bangalore, India won the Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot Court this year, the first time that the annual competition involved four rather than three regions of the world.   Sponsored by the International Institute of Space Law (IISL), Africa joined North America, Europe and Asia-Pacific as one of the regions fielding teams.

Each region holds initial competitive rounds from which one team each is chosen to advance to the semi-finals.   Those four teams compete in semi-finals, and the two winners move on to the finals, arguing their cases before a panel of three judges from the International Court of Justice (ICJ).  The semi-finals and finals are held in conjunction with the annual IISL colloquium, which is part of the International Astronautical Congress (IAC).  The IAC was held in Naples, Italy this year.

The winners of the African round were from the Obafemi Awolowo University in the City of Ile-Ife, Nigeria, and initially were denied visas to enter Italy.  The situation was resolved only at the last minute and the team arrived just hours before its semi-final began.

The Nigerian team unsuccessfully faced off against the winner of the Asia-Pacific round, India.   In the other semi-final competition, the winner of the European round, the National & Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece, won over the North American team from the University of California at Davis.    Thus the final match was India versus Greece. 

The Indian team won not only the overall competition, but the Eilene M. Galloway award for best brief and the Sterns & Tennen award for best oralist.

In all, 54 universities around the world fielded teams as part of this competition, which involved a hypothetical case where one country removed another country’s satellite from orbit without authorization because the first country decided the satellite was a space debris hazard.

The case for the 2013 Manfred Lachs Moot Court has been published on IISL’s website.  The finals will be held in Beijing, China in October 2013 in conjunction with the next IISL colloquium.

Top Democratic House Appropriator Warns about Sequestration

Top Democratic House Appropriator Warns about Sequestration

Rep. Norman Dicks (D-WA), the top Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, is warning about the impact of sequestration not only on the defense budget, but to non-defense agencies like NASA and NOAA as well.

With the clock ticking down to January 2, 2013 when sequestration goes into effect (unless Congress acts to prevent it), focus is broadening to include its impact on non-defense agencies.   Until now, the 9.4 percent cut to the defense budget has been drawing the most attention, but all other government agencies in the so-called discretionary part of the budget will be hit with an 8.2 percent cut.   A report released by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) last month spells out the cuts by budget account in every affected agency.

Republicans and Democrats are both using the sequestration drama as part of their political toolboxes for the upcoming elections with each blaming the other for the inability to agree on another method for reducing the deficit.  Dicks released a “dear colleague” letter on October 9 on the “consequences” of sequestration.    After reviewing the oft-recited dangers to the DOD budget, he moves on to homeland security, public safety, protection of financial markets, international affairs, education, “health, science, and innovation,” and safety-net programs.

The impact on non-defense space programs is mentioned under both public safety and in health, science and innovation.

Concerning public safety, Dicks points to cuts in NOAA’s procurement of weather satellites that would cause “a 2- to 4-year period in which weather data from NOAA’s polar orbiting satellite [sic] would be unavailable, putting American communities at greater risk from tornadoes, hurricanes and other weather events.”

As for NASA, he writes that “Funding cuts would cripple NASA’s efforts to establish U.S. commercial capability to transport American astronauts to the International Space Station” and “effectively extend the period of U.S. dependence on Russia.”  That means it would not be “true savings” since the United States would have to pay “at least $63 million per seat” to Russia.

Dicks is in his final months as a Member of Congress.  He announced plans to retire earlier this year.  He was first elected to Congress in 1976 and rose through the ranks of the appropriations committee, chairing the Interior Subcommittee and later the Defense Subcommittee when Democrats were in control.  He is currently ranking member on the defense subcommittee as well as on the full committee.

 

Perry, Lunine to Co-Chair NRC Human Spaceflight Study Committee

Perry, Lunine to Co-Chair NRC Human Spaceflight Study Committee

Former Secretary of Defense Bill Perry and space scientist Jonathan Lunine will co-chair the National Research Council’s new study on the future of the human spaceflight program.

Perry currently is a professor at Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Cooperation.  Lunine is a professor at Cornell University and Director of its Center for Radiophysics and Space Research.

The study was requested by Congress in the 2010 NASA Authorization Act, which directed NASA to contract with the NRC in FY2012 (which ended last month).   The study officially got under way in August, but the co-chairs were named just today; other committee members have not been announced yet.   NRC officials have previously indicated that the study would take about 22 months to complete.

According to its Statement of Task, the committee will “provide findings, rationale, prioritized recommendations, and decision rules that could enable and guide future planning for U.S. human space exploration” for the FY2014-FY2023 time period “while considering the program’s likely evolution in 2015-2030.”

Perry was Secretary of Defense from 1994-1997 after other stints at DOD — including under secretary of defense for research and engineering — and a long business career in high-tech companies.    HIs doctorate is in mathematics and he is a member of the National Academy of Engineering.

Lunine is a highly respected space scientist whose work spans planetary science, theoretical astrophysics and astrobiology.  He is involved in planetary exploration missions like Cassini-Huygens and Juno, and is also a member of the science team for the James Webb Space Telescope.  He is a member of the National Academy of Sciences.

The pairing of two individuals from the often disparate fields of science and engineering parallels NASA’s current effort through the Mars Program Planning Group to develop a Mars exploration strategy that responds both to the agency’s science goals and the President’s directive to send humans to orbit Mars in the 2030s.  NASA’s science programs are closely tied to priorities identified by NRC “decadal surveys” conducted about every 10 years (a decade) for the next 10 years of research.   Lunine was a member of the steering committee for the most recent (2010) decadal survey for astronomy and astrophysics.

Correction:  The spelling of Dr. Lunine’s first name in the first sentence has been corrected, adding the “t” in Jonathan.

Events of Interest: Week of October 14-20, 2012 – UPDATE

Events of Interest: Week of October 14-20, 2012 – UPDATE

UPDATE:   This is Earth Science Week and information about related events has been added in the “During the Week” section.

The following events may be of interest in the week ahead.   Congress remains in recess (except for pro forma sessions) until after the elections.

During the Week

October 14-20 is Earth Science Week, an annual celebration established in 1998 by the American Geophysical Union to help children, students and the general public understand how geoscientists collection information about the planet, according a NASA website.  NASA is planning a number of Internet-based events as well as a Univisión radio interview in Spanish on Tuesday with scientists Erika Podest and Miguel Romain.   The list of NASA-sponsored events is on our calender.  This year NASA is reaching out to the Spanish-speaking community not only with Tuesday’s radio interview on Univisión, but a dedicated section of its Earth Science Week website in Spanish.

Sunday-Friday, October 14-19

  • DPS 2012 (Division on Planetary Science of the American Astronomical Society), Reno, NV

Monday-Thursday, October 15-18

Tuesday, October 16

Wednesday-Thursday, October 17-18

  • ISPCS 2012 (International Symposium for Personal and Commercial Spaceflight), Las Cruces, NM

Thursday, October 18

 

Privately Funded Asteroid Mission Passes Initial Soundness Review

Privately Funded Asteroid Mission Passes Initial Soundness Review

The B612 Foundation announced on Thursday that its Sentinel Special Review Team (SSRT) gave a thumbs up on the technical soundness of the Foundation’s implementation plans and mission design for its Sentinel asteroid hunting mission.   The Foundation, led by former astronauts Ed Lu and Rusty Schweickart, has a Space Act Agreement with NASA to further the goal of launching a privately funded spacecraft to identify and catalog asteroids that could pose a threat to Earth.

The Ball Aerospace-built infrared (IR) space telescope would be placed into a “Venus-trailing” orbit by a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket in 2017 under current plans.  The project is sometimes described as a “commercial” space science mission, but it is more accurate to call it a philanthropic activity.   The Foundation plans to make all the data publicly available, not to sell it or otherwise try to recoup its costs.

In an interview, Lu described the project as being similar to ground-based telescopes such as the Keck telescopes in Hawai and the Allen radio telescope array that were built with money from individuals interested in advancing knowledge.    He said typically philanthropic projects of this magnitude obtain about 50 percent of their funding from a top tier of one, two or three donors, another 30 percent from a second tier of a couple of hundred donors, and the remaining 20 percent from a very large number of smaller donors.  He said most donors to such projects are not motivated by the idea of an “edifice” being erected as a legacy, but by a desire to “give back” and “make a difference.”

An advantage of a project like Sentinel, he adds, is that it is “addressing a problem that will fix a problem” rather than some more nebulous goal.  The problem to be solved is cataloging a larger number of asteroids that could pose a threat to the planet than can be observed using ground-based telescopes. 

The Foundation released the names of the individuals who comprise the SSRT — a veritable who’s who of experts in buiding and managing robotic space programs — chosen by the Foundation or appointed by NASA.    NASA is working with the Foundation through a Space Act Agreement signed in May under which NASA will provide technical advice and use of the Deep Space Network (DSN) to communicate with Sentinel during its 6.5 year mission.  NASA has its own asteroid cataloging activity, but it is limited to ground-based instruments.  The likelihood that the agency will be provided with adequate resources to build and launch its own dedicated asteroid-hunting space telescope is deemed to be very small, hence the Foundation’s efforts to fund the mission privately.

The 11-member SSRT is led by Tom Gavin, former Director of Flight Projects and Mission Success at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), which builds and operates many of NASA’s deep space probes.   Other members include Steve Battel of Battel Engineering, an expert on progam management and systems engineering who just completed six years as a member of the National Academies Space Studies Board; John Casani, who managed the Voyager, Galileo and Cassini missions at JPL and led the independent review of the James Webb Space Telescope program in 2010; and Orlando Figueroa, who retired from NASA after serving as Director of NASA’s Mars Program and who just led a team that outlined options for reconfiguring the Mars exploration program in the wake of budget cuts and a desire to make the program responsive both to the agency’s science and human exploration goals.

The SSRT completed its first “Program Concept and Implementation Review” in September and found that the “implementation plans and mission design, as put forward by the B612 Foundation and its partner Ball Aerospace, are technically sound and will lead to a successful Sentinel mission.” 

The task of the Sentinel project is to catalog asteroids that could threaten Earth, but the B612 Foundation’s goal is much bigger — “to protect the future of humanity on Earth while opening up the solar system.”   Lu and Schweickart have been leaders of the Association of Space Explorers (ASE) effort to promote international planning for how to deflect any asteroids that might have Earth in its sights.  Lu is co-inventor of the “gravity-tractor” concept to alter an asteroid’s trajectory so it would avoid Earth.

 

New Government Travel Restrictions Force AAS to Cancel November Conference

New Government Travel Restrictions Force AAS to Cancel November Conference

The American Astronautical Society (AAS) announced today that it must cancel its annual National Conference in November because new travel restrictions for government employees caused all of the high level NASA officials who were scheduled to speak at the conference to withdraw.  The decision does not affect next week’s AAS Von Braun symposium in Huntsville, AL, which will proceed as scheduled.

AAS President Frank Slazer said in a letter circulated by AAS that the society is not alone in suffering from the absence of government speakers and attendees at its conferences:  “a recent American Meteorological Society conference lost 100 out of 130 NOAA attendees at very short notice,” he wrote.   An AAS conference this summer on International Space Station research also had lower than expected government attendance because of the travel restrictions, he noted.

The November conference was scheduled for November 28-29, 2012 in Pasadena, CA in partnership with the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) and The Planetary Society. 

“Without key NASA and other government speakers and participants, [AAS] leadership made the painful decision to cancel this conference rather than risk the quality of event that we have consistently worked to provide our membership and attendees,” Slazer explained.

The AAS Wernher von Braun Memorial Symposium scheduled for next week in Huntsville, AL, however, is proceeding as scheduled.

Editor’s note:   In the interest of full disclosure, I am Vice President-Public Policy of AAS.   That is not why I make this comment, however.  It is absolutely true that taxpayers’ dollars should not be squandered on unnecessary or exorbitant travel, but meetings of professional societies like AAS provide an opportunity for the public — those very same taxpayers — to learn about what their tax dollars are enabling, and places for the science and engineering communities to interact, leading to better science and engineering.   These new rules are the result of a single agency, the General Services Administration, losing control of its conference planning process, but everyone is being made to suffer.   One can only hope that a more reasonable set of policies that deal with the actual problem will be put in place in the near future.   The Pasadena conference was really going to be terrific — and I say that as a space policy analyst, not an AAS official.  What a shame.