Category: Civil

SLS Useful for Science Missions, Too, STScI Director Tells House Panel

SLS Useful for Science Missions, Too, STScI Director Tells House Panel

The new Space Launch System (SLS) NASA is developing is useful for robotic science missions as well as human spaceflight according to the director of the Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI).

Testifying to a House subcommittee last week, Matt Mountain said that SLS could enable launching telescopes much larger than the Hubble Space Telescope or the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope (JWST).   STScI operates Hubble and will operate JWST after it is launched in 2018.   Mountain described telescopes with primary mirrors 15-25 meters across — three or four times the size of JWST — that might be able to detect life on planets around other stars that would be enabled by a launch vehicle the size of SLS coupled with “human or robotic infrastructure to assemble such a system in space.”  Another science mission that would benefit from an SLS-type rocket is the long-awaited Mars sample return mission, he added.

That comes with two big caveats, however.  First, SLS flights would have to be relatively frequent, at least once a year, he said.  Second, the cost of using SLS could not be borne by whatever science mission needs it.  Those funds would have to come from elsewhere in NASA.   Mountain cited the two decades of Hubble history as a precedent.   Hubble was launched by the space shuttle in 1990 and five astronaut teams serviced it between 1993 and 2009.   “The cost of the space shuttle for Hubble was not fully borne by the Science Mission Directorate, but rather provided as part of NASA’s space flight infrastructure for use by the entire agency,” he explained.   Science should be an “essential and exciting partner” in NASA’s exploration activities, but “cannot drive the development of human spaceflight systems.”

The main purpose of the September 12, 2012 hearing before the Subcommittee on Space and Aeronautics of the House Science, Space and Technology Committee was getting an update from NASA and industry officials on the status of the SLS and the Orion spacecraft.   The SLS/Orion system will launch astronauts to destinations beyond low Earth orbit (LEO). 

Dan Dumbacher, NASA’s deputy associate administrator for exploration systems development, assured the subcommittee that SLS is on track for its first test launch in 2017 and first launch with a crew in 2021.    The Orion spacecraft similarly is on schedule, he said, for a first test launch in 2014 aboard a Delta IV rocket, followed by a second test on the first SLS flight in 2017, and the first crewed flight in 2021.   Jim Chilton of Boeing, the prime contractor for SLS, and Cleon Lacefield of Lockheed Martin, prime contractor for Orion, generally agreed.

Chilton, however, called development of the SLS core stage a “challenge.”  Although the SLS engines and boosters come from the space shuttle program and the upper stage from the Delta IV program, the core stage is a “clean sheet design,” he said.  Another challenge, he added, is that NASA is being held to a flat budget profile meaning that “simultaneous development of all the elements needed to get to the final configuration … won’t be possible.”

Dumbacher expressed confidence, however, that NASA will be able to pull it all together.

Rep. Hansen Clarke (D-MI) asked what impact the Continuing Resolution (CR) for the first six months of FY2013 will have on the SLS and Orion programs.  Dumbacher said he had been given guidance to plan for 50 percent of what those programs received in FY2012, but pointed to continuing uncertainty about FY2013 funding.  He stressed that funding stability is critical.  “Changes to or instability in the funding forces replanned work, re-work … and all of that effort takes away from our ability to actually execute … and build the program.”

What level of funding SLS and Orion would receive under the CR apparently is an issue.   The day after the hearing, Reps. Ed Perlmutter (D-CO) and Lamar Smith (R-TX) wrote a letter to NASA Administrator Charlie Bolden and White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Acting Director Jeffrey Zients urging them to keep the programs funded at their FY 2012 levels.  The letter says: “Unfortunately we have received indications that efforts are underway within NASA and OMB to reduce or slow down the rate of funding….This would be a major mistake.”

Events of Interest: Week of September 17-21, 2012–UPDATE

Events of Interest: Week of September 17-21, 2012–UPDATE

The following events may be of interest in the coming week.  The House and Senate will meet for legislative business beginning on Wednesday; they are in recess early in the week in observance of Rosh Hashanah.   This article was updated Sunday afternoon to add expected House consideration of H.R. 4158 on Wednesday.

During the Week

The first event of interest actually is today (Sunday, September 16) Eastern Daylight Time (EDT), but it will be Monday local time in Kazakhstan.   Three International Space Station crew members are scheduled to land in Kazakhstan at 8:53 am local time, which is 10:53 pm tonight  EDT.   Undocking is scheduled for 7:09 pm EDT today.  NASA TV will cover the undocking beginning at 6:45 pm EDT and of the landing beginning at 9:30 pm EDT.

Later in the week, the Senate is expected to pass the FY2013 Continuing Resolution (CR) that will fund the government through March 27, 2013.  The House passed it last week.

The House is scheduled to meet Wednesday-Friday and then will adjourn until after the elections, returning on November 13.   For all the angst over the catastrophic consequences if Congress does not act to avoid the sequestration that will otherwise go into effect on January 2, 2013, it obviously does not want to deal with the issue until knowing which party will be in control after November 6.   The Office of Management and Budget report released on Friday details just how bad things will be if the sequester takes effect.

One bill the House is expected to take up on Wednesday under suspension of the rules is H.R. 4158 (Hall).  The legislation would confirm full ownership rights to certain astronauts to artifacts from their missions such as personal logs, checklists, or flight manuals, but not lunar rocks or other lunar materials.

Tuesday, September 18

Thursday, September 20

Friday, September 21

Soyuz TMA-04M is Home — Update

Soyuz TMA-04M is Home — Update

Update:  Soyuz TMA-04M landed at 10:53 pm EDT on September 16, 2012.

Original Story:

Three International Space Station (ISS) crew members aboard the Soyuz TMA-04M spacecraft are on their way home.

Undocking took place at 7:09 pm Eastern Daylight Time (EDT).  Landing in Kazakhstan is expected at 10:52 pm EDT.  Russian cosmonauts Gennady Padalka and Sergei Revin, and NASA astronaut Joe Acaba, are aboard.

Stability, Leadership Are Keys To Future Space Program, Witnesses Tell Senate Subcommittee

Stability, Leadership Are Keys To Future Space Program, Witnesses Tell Senate Subcommittee

Witnesses appearing before a Senate subcommittee last week stressed repeatedly that stability and leadership are keys to the future of the U.S. space program.   More money would be nice, they said, but stability is critical.

Steve Squyres, chair of the NASA Advisory Council (NAC), pointed to the mismatch between what NASA is being asked to accomplish by Congress and the Obama Administration versus the resources the agency is provided to meet those goals.  In particular, he is concerned about the “pay as you go” approach to funding the Space Launch System (SLS) and the Orion spacecraft.  That “can result in slow progress if funding levels are not adequate” and the low flight rate could threaten program momentum and the need to keep “flight teams sharp and mission ready.”   He also highlighted the lack of funds for the other parts of a system needed to take astronauts beyond low Earth orbit — hardware to keep crews healthy on long duration missions far from Earth and a lunar lander for “a lunar surface mission which also is to be a stepping stone to Mars.”

A lunar landing mission is not part of the Obama Administration’s plan, but Squyres apparently agrees with the late Neil Armstrong and others who insist that a return to the Moon is a necessary step in future human space exploration.  President Obama believes the next step should be a human mission to an asteroid in 2025.  His program includes no missions to land on either the Moon or Mars through the 2030s; orbiting them, yes, but not landing.

Squyres concluded that the current budget is “insufficient” to carry out the administration’s plan and identified four options to proceed:

  • keep trying to do everything “with an inadequate budget, running the risk of lengthy delays and a job poorly done”;
  • making “painful choices” about what to eliminate in order to preserve funding for higher priorities;
  • increasing the budget “although I realize that might be difficult in a constrained budgetary environment”; or
  • forging strong international partnerships.

Jim Maser, President of Pratt & Whitney Rocketdyne, agreed that a lunar lander will be needed “eventually,” expressing skepticism about the asteroid mission and saying that “fallback plans” are needed.    His main point, however, was the need for “an enduring vision” and a “consistent, clearly articulated budget” to execute it.  Lamenting the Obama Adminstration’s change in direction “with what appears to be limited coordination and consent from Congress” which led to Congress “being compelled to be prescriptive” in law regarding what NASA should build, he called for “an enduring stable vision … that’s set by the President in alignment with Congress and budgets in a consistent manner that enables execution over timeframes that extend beyond a single administration or congressional election cycle.”

Charles Kennel, chair of the National Research Council’s (NRC’s) Space Studies Board, also called for “consistency of vision and goals as essential to achieving leadership in space.” His testimony focused on the importance of the United States maintaining leadership, especially in space science.  The NRC just completed a series of decadal surveys on the various aspects of space and earth science, including biological and physical science research aboard the International Space Station (ISS).  Kennel said the ISS “guarantees our leadership” for a decade in human spaceflight, but asked what comes next.  Congress directed NASA to contract with the NRC in FY2012 (which ends on September 30) to conduct a study and make recommendations on the future of the human spaceflight program.   Kennel said the members of that study committee are about to be announced and will be a “distinguished” group.

Kennel and Squyres both lamented the cancellation of NASA’s cooperation with the European Space Agency (ESA) on robotic Mars exploration because of cutbacks in the FY2013 budget request.   ESA is now partnering with Russia on the 2016 and 2018 ExoMars missions instead of NASA, but financial difficulties still must be resolved.   Despite the United States leaving ESA in the lurch, the potential of international cooperation to enable achieving bold goals in space was heralded at the hearing.

Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX), who is retiring at the end of this term, asked whether NASA’s mission should be more narrowly focused by moving aeronautics elsewhere, for example.   Squyres, Kennel and Maser all argued against it, pointing out that the aeronautics budget is so small it would not make much of a difference in pursuing NASA’s space activities and that aeronautics research is critically important to the nation.   Squyres, who is a planetary scientist, said that as chair of NAC he has come to learn a lot about NASA’s aeronautics program. “Disrupting the program — trying to rip it out of the place where it’s found such a good home and place it somewhere else could be detrimental to what I think is one of the best things that NASA does,” he said.

Squyres is best known as the principal investigator for the Mars Exploration Rovers Spirit and Opportunity that landed on Mars in 2004.  He also chaired the recent NRC decadal survey on planetary science.   Robotic Mars exploration was one focus of the hearing, which led off with witnesses representing the Mars Curiosity mission that landed on Mars last month.  Fuk Li, Director of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory’s Mars Exploration Directorate and CalTech’s John Grotzinger, Curiosity’s lead scientist, updated the subcommittee on the Curiosity mission.

Senator Bill Nelson (D-FL), chair of the subcommittee, asked about the utility of SLS for science missions.  Similar in capability to the Saturn V that sent Apollo astronauts to the Moon, the SLS will be optimized for human spaceflight missions, but Nelson asked about other missions SLS could enable.   Kennel offered that a mission to deflect an asteroid that might impact the Earth is one possibility, along with robotic sample return missions from Mars.  Squyres said that human missions to asteroids and Mars could be important from a planetary science standpoint.  He pointed out that the science that has been achieved with the Opportunity rover over eight years could have been accomplished in a week or week-and-a-half with a human crew.

The September 12 hearing was before the Science and Space subcommittee of the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee.    

Suni Williams Takes Command of ISS; Only Second Woman Commander

Suni Williams Takes Command of ISS; Only Second Woman Commander

NASA astronaut Sunita (Suni) Williams ceremonially took command of the International Space Station (ISS) today from departing commander Gennady Padalka.  Williams is only the second woman to command the ISS in its nearly 12 years of permanent occupancy.

Russia’s Padalka and Sergei Revin and NASA’s Joe Acaba are getting ready to return to Earth in their Soyuz TMA-04M spacecraft after approximately six months aboard the ISS.  They are scheduled to undock tomorrow, September 16, at 7:09 pm Eastern Daylight Time (EDT) and land in Kazakhstan at 10:53 pm EDT (8:53 am September 17 local time in Kazakshtan).  An earlier NASA press release said undocking was at 7:11 pm, but the NASA space station website today says 7:09 pm.

The traditional Change-of-Command ceremony took place today, although officially Padalka remains in command until he departs.

Williams will remain onboard with Russia’s Yuri Malenchenko and Japan’s Aki Hoshide.   They will be joined by three more ISS crew members next month — NASA’s Kevin Ford and Russia’s Oleg Novitsky and Evgeny Tarelkin.  The Williams crew is scheduled to return to Earth on November 12.

NASA’s Peggy Whitson was the first woman to command ISS in 2009.  As Itar-Tass, Russia’s official news service, noted, Whitson commanded “only” two men while Williams will have five (three Russians, an American and a Japanese) under her command.  Women do not figure prominently in Russia’s cosmonaut corps.  Although the Soviet Union launched the first woman into space, Valentina Tereshkova, in 1963, only two more female cosmonauts have gone into space since then:  Svetlana Savitskaya, the first woman to perform a spacewalk and the first woman to make two spaceflights (1982 and 1984); and Yelena Kondakova in 1995, who set a spaceflight duration record for a woman at that time.   Savitskaya’s flights were on the Soviet Salyut 7 space station; Kondakova was aboard Mir.  No Russian female cosmonauts have been part of the International Space Station crews.

By comparison, women have flown on U.S. space missions routinely since 1984 when Sally Ride became the first American woman in space.   Kathy Sullivan was the first U.S. woman to make a spacewalk, soon after Savitskaya’s in 1984.   The fact that Sullivan would be making a spacewalk was known well in advance and it is widely believed that the Soviets arranged one for Savitiskaya so they could claim another space “first,” a signature feature of the Cold War era space race.

Women from Canada, Japan, France, and China also have flown into space as part of their countries’ astronaut corps.   Other women have flown as payload specialists on the U.S. space shuttle or as paying “tourists” — from the United States (one of whom is Iranian-American and is sometimes counted as Iranian), United Kingdom, and South Korea.

Williams currently holds the record for spacewalk duration by a woman: 44 hours and two minutes accumulated over six spacewalks — four on a previous ISS tour of duty and two on this one.   Whitson is second, with 39 hours 46 minutes also over six spacewalks.

White House Report on Sequestration Details Severe Impacts on NASA, NOAA and DOD

White House Report on Sequestration Details Severe Impacts on NASA, NOAA and DOD

The White House today released the report required by Congress detailing the impact of sequestration if it goes into effect in January.  The report was due last week, but was not submitted until now.

The report from the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) was required by the Sequestration Transparency Act, passed by Congress just before it left for its August recess.  Running 394 pages, it provides agency-by-agency details on what FY2013 funding is subject to the sequester and what is exempt, and then what percentage and dollar amount would be cut from the sequestrable funds.  

The White House describes the report as preliminary, saying that actual cuts would “differ based on changes in law and ongoing legal, budgetary and technical analysis.”  It also points out that since Congress has not passed any of the FY2013 appropriations bills, the estimates are based on FY2012 appropriations.

For NASA, just about everything is subject to an 8.2 percent sequester except for $2.3 billion in the Cross-Agency Support category, which funds operations of the NASA centers and other infrastructure costs.   NOAA’s Operations, Research and Facilities (ORF) account and its Procurement, Acquisition and Construction (PAC) account, both would be cut by 8.2 percent as well.  The PAC account funds the JPSS and GOES-R weather satellite procurements.  The report includes a paragraph with examples of the non-defense programs that would be jeopardized under sequestration, but neither NASA nor NOAA are called out.

Department of Defense (DOD) accounts generally would be cut 9.4 percent.   DOD would be able to shift funds to “ensure war fighting and critical military readiness capabilities were not degraded,” but sequestration would negatively impact readiness, investments in new equipment and facilities, repairs, R&D, and base services for military families according to the report.

Overall, the report says sequestration “would have a devastating impact on important defense and nondefense programs.”

Under last year’s Budget Control Act, the sequester will go into effect on January 2, 2013 unless Congress and the White House agree on another method of reducing the deficit by $1.2 trillion by the year 2021.  The sequester was included as a “poison pill” to motivate congressional Republicans and Democrats to reach a deal last fall, but they did not.  As today’s report says “The sequestration itself was never intended to be implemented.”  It goes on to put the onus on Congress to fix the problem: “The Administration strongly believes that sequestration is bad policy, and the Congress can and should take action to avoid it by passing a comprehensive and balanced deficit reduction package.”

The two parties remain at loggerheads on how to reduce the deficit.  The Republicans want to achieve the reduction entirely through spending cuts while Democrats want a combination of spending cuts and tax increases.

Neil Armstrong Buried at Sea (Photo)

Neil Armstrong Buried at Sea (Photo)

Neil Armstrong, the first man to walk on the Moon, was buried at sea today.

Armstrong’s cremains were committed to the sea aboard the USS Philippine Sea in the Atlantic Ocean by a Navy honor guard.

Photo credit:  Bill Ingalls, NASA

Armstrong was commemorated at a public memorial service yesterday at the National Cathedral in Washington, DC.   NASA has posted the video on YouTube.   

CR Lets NOAA Fully Fund Weather Sats, But Other Programs Would Pay Price

CR Lets NOAA Fully Fund Weather Sats, But Other Programs Would Pay Price

The six-month FY2013 Continuing Resolution (CR) Congress is getting ready to pass would allow NOAA to fully fund the Joint Polar Satellite System (JPSS) and Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite-R (GOES-R) system, but other programs in NOAA’s Procurement, Acquisition and Construction (PAC) account would have to pay the price.  The CR will fund the first half of FY2013.

The CR allows NOAA to shift money within its PAC account that includes the funds to build JPSS and GOES-R, but does not increase the amount of funding to match the request for FY2013.   CRs typically continue an agency’s funding at its previous year’s level, a distinct disadvantage for programs that are ramping up.   The FY2013 request for JPSS is little different from its FY2012 funding level ($916 million for FY2013 compared to $924 million in FY2012), so is not much of an issue.  GOES-R however, needs a substantial boost to begin acquisition of a launch vehicle for the first in that series.  GOES-R got $616 million in FY2012, while the FY2013 request is $802 million.  

Under the CR, NOAA could take money from other programs in the PAC account to keep JPSS and GOES-R on schedule.  NOAA received $1.81 billion for PAC in FY2012, the level to which it will be held under the CR, compared to the $1.97 billion requested for FY2013.   Satellites are far and away the lion’s share of the PAC funding already:  $1.7 billion in FY2012 and $1.85 billion in the FY2013 request.   In addition to JPSS and GOES-R, that funds two other satellite programs, DSCOVR and Jason-3.   DSCOVR, formerly called Triana, will provide space weather data considered critical to the Air Force, NASA and NOAA who are splitting the costs of getting it ready and launching it.  It is scheduled for a slight decrease in FY2013 anyway, but Jason-3, a joint ocean altimetry mission with Europe, is due for a $10 million increase to its $20 million FY2012 budget.

The CR also requires the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to submit a report to Congress within 30 days of the bill becoming law that sets out a plan for the two satellite programs to maintain their schedules and life cycle cost estimates and options for reducing those costs, including management costs.

That language appears to respond to the recommendation of the Senate Appropriations Committee in its version of the FY2013 Commerce, Justice, Science appropriations bill that NOAA’s weather satellite programs be transferred to NASA.  That committee is concerned about rising costs and shortcomings it sees in NOAA’s management of satellite programs.   With passage of the FY2013 appropriations bills delayed for at least six months, the language in the CR keeps a focus on the underlying problems without changing which agency is in charge.   NASA already is the acquisition agent for NOAA’s satellites, but NOAA sets the requirements and is the program manager.

Mike Collins, Gene Cernan to Speak At Memorial Service for Neil Armstrong Tomorrow

Mike Collins, Gene Cernan to Speak At Memorial Service for Neil Armstrong Tomorrow

NASA will broadcast the public memorial service for Neil Armstrong tomorrow at 10:00 am ET.  Armstrong died last month at the age of 82.

The service is being held at the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C.   The program for the service shows that Mike Collins, command module pilot on the Apollo11 mission, and Apollo 17 commander Gene Cernan both will speak.   NASA administrator Charlie Bolden also will speak.

On July 20, 1969, Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first humans to walk on the Moon while Collins orbited overhead.  In 1972, Cernan commanded the last Apollo lunar landing mission, Apollo 17, and was the last human being to walk on the Moon.

NASA’s TV coverage will begin at 9:45 am ET.  NASA chief historian Bill Barry will conduct an online chat on Ustream during the service providing more information about the speakers at http://www.ustream.tv/nasahdtv.

A private memorial service was held earlier.

 

Lacefield, Chilton Added as Witnesses for Tomorrow's Hearing

Lacefield, Chilton Added as Witnesses for Tomorrow's Hearing

Jim Chilton from Boeing and Cleon Lacefield from Lockheed Martin are joining the list of witnesses at tomorrow’s House Science, Space and Technology subcommittee hearing.

The hearing is on the Space Launch System and Orion spacecraft.  NASA’s Dan Dumbacher and the Space Telescope Science Institute’s Matt Mountain are the other witnesses.   The hearing is at 10:00 am ET tomorrow in 2318 Rayburn House Office Building.