Category: International

Still No Deal on Fiscal Cliff, But Talks Continue After Tense Day

Still No Deal on Fiscal Cliff, But Talks Continue After Tense Day

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) told the Senate just before 6:00 pm ET that talks with Republicans would continue on how to avert the fiscal cliff. The statement came after a tense day where earlier he had said the talks were at an impasse because Republicans wanted to add a provision that would change how Social Security cost of living increases are calculated.

As the afternoon began, Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) criticized Reid for taking so long to respond to a proposal Republicans made the previous evening. McConnell told the Senate that he had sent a proposal to Reid about 7:00 pm ET Saturday evening, but had received no response by 2:00 pm this afternoon.  Reid then took the floor and replied that he had no counteroffer to make.  While complimenting McConnell for negotiating in good faith, Reid said the two were simply too far apart on “some pretty big issues.”

The focus of the talks has been on tax rates and other tax breaks that will expire at midnight tomorrow.  Aides to Reid were quoted as saying that now is not the time to bring Social Security benefits into the debate.

The Senate recessed to allow each party to caucus and determine how to proceed. Republicans emerged insisting that they did not know that the proposed change — using the chained price index to calculate cost of living increases, which would reduce those increases — was a dealbreaker and they would take the issue off the table.  About two hours later, Reid returned to the floor and said he was happy to hear it, and talks would continue.  He said there is still time for a deal, but his manner did not convey optimism.

As for the automatic spending cuts that will take place on January 2 — the sequester — several media sources that closely follow Capitol Hill politics are reporting that there is virtually no chance that Congress will act to stop it.  How long it would take for the draconian cuts — 9.4 percent for defense, 8.2 percent for the rest of discretionary spending — to impact government and contractor personnel and programs is a matter of debate.  Since it begins with cuts to spending in FY2013, which is already underway, people are getting increasingly nervous.

Nothing is certain until the deadlines pass, of course, and even then the 113th Congress — which begins on Thursday — can fix problems left by the 112th.  Aphorisms like “it’s always darkest before the dawn” or “it ain’t over till the fat lady sings” may be cliches, but they also often are true.  If the stock market continues its decline tomorrow, the parties may be motivated to find a solution.

 

No Fiscal Cliff Deal Yet, Failure to Fix Sequestration "Dereliction of Duty" Says Blakey

No Fiscal Cliff Deal Yet, Failure to Fix Sequestration "Dereliction of Duty" Says Blakey

With half of the 48 hours gone already, Senate Democratic and Republican leaders still have not reached a deal to avert the fiscal cliff.   Meanwhile, Aerospace Industries Association (AIA) President Marion Blakey issued a stern warning today about the impact on the aerospace sector if sequestration goes into effect.

After a meeting at the White House yesterday,  Senator Democratic Leader Harry Reid (NV) and Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (KY) agreed to spend the weekend trying to reach an agreement that would pass the Senate and, hopefully, the House before the clock strikes midnight on Monday, December 31.  A deal is expected to be presented to their respective caucuses tomorrow afternoon.  

The Senate was in session Thursday and Friday, but not today.  The House has been in recess since before Christmas.  Both chambers are scheduled to meet tomorrow in a rare Sunday session.  House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) alerted Members that the House could remain in session through January 2.   That is the last possible day for the 112th Congress.  The 113th Congress, with new and returning members elected on November 6, begins on Thursday.  All pending legislation dies at the end of a Congress.   Democratic Senators reportedly are drafting legislation to be introduced as soon as the 113th Congress convenes to cut tax rates if no agreement is reached before then.

Few details have been made public about what progress is being made other than that tax rates remain at the heart of the disagreement.   Republicans have insisted all along that tax rates should remain the same for all income levels while President Obama wants tax rates for the wealthiest individuals to return to levels prior to the George W. Bush Administration.  President Obama is calling for rates for those who earn over $250,000 to go up, but recently indicated he would compromise at $400,000.   House Speaker Boehner attempted to win support from his Republican caucus for the higher rates to apply only to those with incomes $1 million or more, but that was rejected.

The tax increases — not only from the expiration of the Bush-era tax cuts, but a number of other expiring provisions such as adjustments to the Alternative Minimum Tax, estate tax reductions, tax credits for college tuition, and the payroll tax holiday — are only one part of the fiscal cliff scenario.   Extended unemployment benefits will expire and Medicare reimbursements to doctors will be cut if Congress does not act. 

Another leg of the stool is sequestration — deep cuts to defense and non-defense discretionary spending.  AIA has been leading the charge all year on highlighting the dire impacts to the defense aerospace sector as well as NASA and NOAA if the spending cuts take place.  Under the Budget Control Act (BCA) of 2011, defense spending would be cut 9.4 percent and NASA and NOAA (and other government non-defense discretionary spending) would be cut 8.2 percent. 

Blakey starkly warned today that if Congress does not fix the sequestration problem it will be a “grave dereliction of duty.”  Agreeing that budget cuts are needed to deal with the deficit, she insisted that sequestration is “the wrong way to do it” and a “mindless meataxe approach that will cause immense disruption and harm our economy and national security.”

Republicans agreed to the defense cuts when the BCA was passed in August 2011, but changed their minds this year and now are seeking to exempt defense from the cuts and reduce government spending elsewhere in exchange, such as by entitlement reform or changes to the tax code (but not tax rates).  Democrats want at least some cuts to defense, for which spending mushroomed during the past decade with the Iraq and Afghan wars.

President Obama said in his weekly address today that if all else fails, he wants the Senate to vote on a modest package that would keep tax rates at their current levels for people with incomes under $250,000, extend unemployment insurance, and set the stage for future progress on the other issues.  He said he believes such a package could pass both the House and Senate if it is allowed to come to a vote.  “That’s the way this is supposed to work,” he said, adding that “We just can’t afford a politically self-inflicted wound to our economy.”

In the Republican response, Senator Roy Blunt (R-MO) criticized Democrats on a broad range of issues ending with his own warning against going over the fiscal cliff.  He gave no hint of what compromise might be in the works, reiterating Republican assertions that it is up to the President to lead.

In essence, today seems like politics as usual.  For those who want to avoid falling off the fiscal cliff, one can only hope that the behind-the-scenes deliberations are more productive.

Progress Reported on Fiscal Cliff Deal After White House Meeting

Progress Reported on Fiscal Cliff Deal After White House Meeting

The top Democrat and the top Republican in the Senate reportedly are jointly working on a plan to avoid the fiscal cliff after a meeting at the White House this afterrnoon of top congressional leaders and the President.

Details are sketchy, but multiple news sources are reporting that Senator Harry Reid (D-NV) and Senator Mitch McConnell (R-KY) agreed to spend the weekend trying to come up with a deal that will pass muster with both parties on both sides of Capitol Hill.  The Senate returned to work yesterday; the House will meet for legislative business on Sunday.

The news came after a one-hour meeting among top House and Senate Democratic and Republican leaders and President Obama, Vice President Biden, and top advisors.   The President said at a press conference after the meeting that if Reid and McConnell are unable to reach a bipartisan agreement, he will press for a Democratic proposal to be put forward instead for an up and down vote that would protect the middle class from tax increases, extend unemployment benefits, and lay the “groundwork for future cooperation on more economic growth and deficit reduction.”  He said he believed such a measure would pass both chambers if the leaders would allow it to come to a vote.  He called the meeting today “constructive.”

Russia Plans To Spend $70 Billion On Space as ILS Stresses Independent Review of Proton Anomaly

Russia Plans To Spend $70 Billion On Space as ILS Stresses Independent Review of Proton Anomaly

Despite a very recent malfunction that added to Russia’s growing list of launch vehicle anomalies, high level Russian government officials are touting the future of the country’s space program and a return to the capabilities under the Soviet-era.

Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev told Russia’s news agency RIA Novosti that Russia will spend 2.1 trillion rubles, about $70 billion, for development of its space industry over the 2013-2020 time period. The total will enable Russia to “effectively participate in forward-looking projects, such as the ISS, the study of the Moon, Mars, and other celestial bodies in the solar system,” he said.

Separately, Russian space agency director Vladimir Popovkin told Russia’s Itar-Tass news agency that “By 2015 we shall restore the capabilities we had back in the Soviet era, and in 2015-2020 we are to create conditions for a breakthrough on the basis of new technologies.”

These bold statements were not accompanied by many details. For example, it is not clear exactly what is included in the 2.1 trillion ruble ($70 billion) figure. That funding spans eight years, so is on average $8.75 billion per year. Medvedev said it includes “extrabudgetary” sources implying it is more than what the Russian government budget will fund. Presumably it includes payments the United States makes to Russia for crew transportation and other services related to the International Space Station (ISS) — about $450 million per year according to NASA.

It might also include money the Russian space industry earns through commercial launches. According to The Space Report 2012, published by the Space Foundation, in 2011 Russia conducted 10 commercial launches, or 56 percent of the global commercial space launch market. How much it earned from those launches is not public, and whether it will retain that percentage of the market — and thereby contribute to the overall total of how much Russia invests in its space program — may depend on restoring confidence in Russia’s launch vehicle fleet.

Russia has endured an unusual two years of launch vehicle failures that may give prospective customers second thoughts. The most recent anomaly, of a Proton rocket’s Briz upper stage, placed Russia’s Yamal 402 communications satellite into the wrong orbit. Although ground controllers were able to use the satellite’s own propulsion system to eventually boost the satellite into the correct position, the fuel usage will reduce the satellite’s operational lifetime from 15 years to 11 years.

The incident underscored continuing concerns about the health of the Russian space industry. The launch was conducted by International Launch Services (ILS).  It issued a statement today that various root causes of the failure are still being evaluated. RIA Novosti reported yesterday that Roscosmos has concluded a bad bearing in a turbopump was the problem, but the ILS statement stresses that it formed its own independent failure review oversight board to look at the Russian government’s findings.  It will not issue its own final report until its independent review is completed. 

The Russian government has been conducting an intensive review of the space sector, led by Medvedev and Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin. The statements to the Russian press today signal that the government plans to shore up its support of the space program, building on a substantial increase in government space spending last year. The Space Report 2012 states that the Russian government’s calendar year 2011 planned spending was $4.12 billion, a 21.2 percent increase over the previous year. By comparison, it calculated total U.S. government space spending (military and civil) in 2011 at $47.25 billion, a 0.4 percent decrease.

Precisely where Russia’s $70 billion announced today will go over the next eight years is unclear. RIA Novosti quotes Dmitry Paison, director of development for the Skolkovo space cluster, as saying the money is for “the Federal Space Program, the Federal Special Program for the Development of the Glonass system, the program for the development of space launch centers and the non-classified part of the program for the technical modernization of the industry.” Paison’s omission of classified programs is understandable, but leaves open the question of what other space spending the Russian government plans that is not public.

Glonass is Russia’s navigation satellite system, analogous to the U.S. GPS system, and a high priority of the Putin government. The head of the company that builds and manages the program recently left his job — some say he was fired, others say he left due to illness — after an investigation found the company embezzled $200 million of government funding.

Popovkin also said today that the current Russian share of the “world market of space services” will rise from 10 percent today to 16 percent, though he did not say over what time period. By comparison, he said the United States has 60 percent of that market “including production and the services provided” and that the United States controls “about 70 percent of the television and radio market.”   The source of his data was not mentioned.   As already noted, in 2011 Russia had 56 percent of the commercial launch services market, while the United States conducted no commercial launches. The Space Report 2012 further states that the United States had 38 percent of the world market for commercial satellite manufacturing, down from 51 percent the prior year (no figure was provided for Russia). Country-by-country breakdowns of other market segments, such as commercial space products and services, including satellite communications and broadcasting, also are not provided in that report.

The bottom line is that although many details are missing, the statements by Medvedev and Popovkin convey that the Russian government plans to step up its investment in space activities.

Indeed, during the past year Russia has announced plans for additional space-based telescopes and robotic lunar probes, joined in Europe’s ExoMars program, announced progress in developing a replacement for the venerable Soyuz spaceship that takes crews to the ISS, and expressed continued interest in building a new launch site at Vostochny in the far eastern region of the country. Some of these plans have been in the works for many years, making claims of progress only mildly credible, but at a time of duress in the Russian space program, the vote of confidence from top government leaders undoubtedly comes as welcome news to the Russian space industry and, presumably, its customers.

Events of Interest: Weeks of December 24, 2012 – January 4, 2013

Events of Interest: Weeks of December 24, 2012 – January 4, 2013

Ordinarily we’d be explaining that there are no interesting events for a couple of weeks while everyone celebrates the holidays, but this is not an ordinary year.  Here’s what we know — and don’t know — as 2012 ends and 2013 begins.

During the Weeks

It is totally unclear as to what will happen in Washington in the next two weeks with one exception — the 112th Congress will end and the 113th Congress will begin.  (Congresses last for two years.)  Whether the members of the 112th Congress can reach agreement to avoid the fiscal cliff that otherwise will occur in this time period or leave the mess to be cleaned up by the 113th Congress is anyone’s guess. 

The House recessed on Thursday with no fixed date to return for legislative business (it is scheduled to meet only in pro forma session).  House Speaker John Boehner reportedly told his House Republican Conference they were going home until after Christmas and perhaps for the rest of the year after he was unable to round up enough votes in his own party to pass his “Plan B” alternative to President Obama’s latest fiscal cliff avoidance offer.   Boehner’s Plan B included raising taxes on the wealthiest people (over $1 million) and conservative Republicans refused to agree.  They have consistently opposed any new taxes.  

The President responded by saying that he still thinks at least some sort of deal can be reached before the end of the year if everyone is willing to compromise.  He then headed off for his annual Christmas vacation in Hawaii, where he grew up, ready to return to Washington on Wednesday if progress is being made.  The Senate also is in recess with only pro forma sessions scheduled.  It is in the middle of debating a supplemental appropriations bill for the victims of Hurricane Sandy.

Some Washington pundits are trying to ratchet down the “fiscal cliff” rhetoric by calling it a “fiscal slope” to telegraph that the impacts may be more gradual than the word “cliff” implies.  In fact, from a political standpoint, there may be an advantage in letting the tax breaks expire on December 31.   The politicians could quickly pass new legislation in January to return the tax rates to the pre-December 31 level for everyone except the wealthiest people (whether that’s over $250,000 as the President had been insisting, over $400,000 as he recently compromised, or $1 million as Speaker Boenher proposed).   That would count as a tax cut rather than a tax increase and thereby not violate anyone’s pledge to never vote for a tax increase.  As for sequestration, it might be relatively easy to simply delay when it would go into effect, giving everyone time to come up with a better solution, even though they have not been able to find one in the past 17 months.

Two smaller space policy-related items on the “to do” list before the end of the year:

  • Congress needs to pass and the President to sign legislation to extend authority for the FAA to indemnify launch service companies from third party claims for certain amounts of money (existing authority expires December 31); and
  • The President needs to sign the FY2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which the House and Senate passed late last week, including a number of important space-related provisions such as easing export controls on satellites.

The House had scheduled a vote last week on H.R. 6612 (McCarthy) to rename NASA’s Dryden Flight Research Center after Neil Armstrong, but it was never brought up.   There was no public word about progress on S. 3661 (Nelson-Hutchison), which would extend the indemnification provision, provide NASA with another waiver to the Iran-North Korea-Syria Nonproliferation Act (INKSNA) so it can purchase services from Russia for the International Space Station, and give NASA a mandate to explore cis-lunar space.  The House passed a bill in November to extend the indemnification provision only (H.R. 6586, Palazzo) that is awaiting Senate action. 

So all of those bills are still in play until the 112th Congress adjourns “sine die”  — “without a day” to reconvene, meaning the 112th Congress is over.  All pending legislation dies at the end of a Congress.   The 113th Congress will convene on January 3 with the new and returning members who were elected on November 6 and the cycle starts over again for the next two years.

Otherwise, we have only one specific space policy-related event on the calendar for the next two weeks:

Friday, January 4, 2013

Soyuz TMA-07M Launches with Three New ISS Crew Members-UPDATE

Soyuz TMA-07M Launches with Three New ISS Crew Members-UPDATE

UPDATE:   Soyuz TMA-07M and its trio of ISS crew members docked with the space station as scheduled today (Dec. 21) at 9:09 am ET.

The Soyuz TMA-07M spacecraft lifted off on time at 7:12 am Eastern Standard Time (EST) this morning, taking three new crew members to the International Space Station (ISS).  Everything seems to be going well at the moment.

NASA’s Tom Marshburn, Canada’s Chris Hadfield, and Russia’s Roman Romanenko began their journey from the Baikonur Cosmodrome at 6:12 pm local time at the launch site (6:12 am CST in Houston,TX, home of NASA’s Mission Control).  They are scheduled to dock with the ISS on Friday at 9:10 am EST (8:10 am CST) and join the three ISS crew members already aboard:  NASA’s Kevin Ford and Russia’s Oleg Novitsky and Evgeny Tarelkin.  That will return the ISS to its normal crew complement of six.

Hadfield will become the first Canadian commander of the ISS later in this mission.

Three ISS Crew Members Set to Launch Wednesday Morning EST

Three ISS Crew Members Set to Launch Wednesday Morning EST

Three new crew members for the International Space Station (ISS) are due to launch at 7:12 am Eastern Standard Time (EST) tomorrow morning, Wednesday, December 19.  The launch will be at 6:12 am Central Standard Time or 6:12 pm local time at the launch site in Kazakhstan.

NASA TV will cover the launch of Soyuz TMA-07M live beginning at 6:00 am EST (5:00 am CST).   The three crew members are:

  • NASA astronaut Tom Marshburn
  • Canadian astronaut Chris Hadfield, who will become the first Canadian ISS commander later in his mission
  • Russian cosmonaut Roman Romanenko
Events of Interest: Week of December 17-21, 2012

Events of Interest: Week of December 17-21, 2012

The following events may be of interest in the week ahead.  The House and Senate will be in session.

During the Week

On Monday,. NASA will have commentary on the splatdown of the two GRAIL probes that have been orbiting the Moon since the beginning of the year.  There is no video coverage of the impact of the probes onto the lunar surface at approximately 2:28 pm PT (5:28 pm ET), but experts will provide commentary as the end comes for the two spacecraft that have exhausted their fuel supplies.

On Tuesday, the House will vote on a bill (H.R. 6612) to rename NASA’s Dryden Flight Research Center after the late Neil Armstrong.

Sometime during the week, It is possible the Senate could act on S. 3661, a Nelson-Hutchison bill to amend the Iran-North Korea-Syria (INKSNA) act to allow NASA to purchase services from Russia for the International Space Station after July 2016, to extend third party liability indemnification for launch services companies for two years, and to make it clear that NASA should explore cis-lunar space.   It also could act on the House-passed H.R. 6586 (Palazzo) that only extends the third party liability indemnification.  The FAA’s authority to provide that indemnification ends on December 31, so that is a must-pass provision.

On Wednesday, the National Research Council will hold the first public meeting of its Committee on Human Spaceflight.  The members of the parent committee — chaired by former Secretary of Defense Bill Perry and Cornell space scientist Jonathan Lunine — were named last month.  The members of one of its two panels, on Technical Feasibility, were named last week.   The meeting is at the National Academy of Sciences building at 21st Street and Constitution Avenue, not at the Keck Building on 5th Street where NRC meetings usually are held.

Also on Wednesday, three new International Space Station crew members will launch from the Baikonur Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan.

Meanwhile everyone is awaiting action on the fiscal cliff.

Those and other events of interest are listed below.

Monday, December 17

Tuesday, December 18

Wednesday, December 19

Wednesday-Thursday, December 19-20

 

NBC: North Korean Satellite Tumbling Out of Control

NBC: North Korean Satellite Tumbling Out of Control

NBC News is quoting unnamed U.S. officials saying that North Korea’s satellite is “tumbling out of control.”

Jim Miklszewski and Alan Byole also report that Russia has joined China in criticizing the launch.  Both had warned North Korea not to conduct the launch, which violates United Nations Security Council resolutions.   The United States, Japan and South Korea condemned the launch before before and after it took place.  The U.N. Security Council  and U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said today they “deplored” the launch.

The launch surprised almost everyone.  North Korea had announced that it planned to conduct a launch between December 10 and 22, but then said the launch would be delayed for a week because of technical problems.  It was not., however, with launch of the Unha-3 rocket with its Kwangmyongsong-3 satellite taking place on December 11 Eastern  Standard Time (December 12 local time in North Korea as well as GMT).

 

North Korea Launches Objects Into Earth Orbit

North Korea Launches Objects Into Earth Orbit

The North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD) confirmed today (December 11 Eastern Standard Time; December 12 local time in North Korea as well as GMT) that North Korea successfully placed at least one object into Earth orbit.  The launch comes despite recent North Korean statements that the launch would be delayed, and amid international condemnation that it would launch anything.

NORAD acknowledged in a statement that North Korea launched a “missile” that “deployed an object that appeared to achieve orbit.”

Just two days ago, North Korea said it was postponing the launch, scheduled for sometime in the December 10-22 time frame, for unspecified reasons.   A later report said the launch of its Unha rocket would be delayed for one week.   Those reports clearly were wrong, with North Korea launching within its originally specified time frame.  North Korea says the Kwangmyungsong-3 satellite is for Earth observations.

This is that country’s fourth attempt — and apparently the first successful — to put a satellite into orbit.  The most recent failure was in April 2012.

Jonathan McDowell, a veteran space launch watcher who publishes Jonathan’s Space Report, tweeted (@ planet4589) that three objects are in orbit “probably payload, rocket stage and attach hardware.”

The launch violates two United Nations Security Resolutions designed to dissuade North Korea from launching ballistic missiles, which are close cousins of satellite launchers.  Japan and the United States reportedly have requested a Security  Council meeting tomorrow to discuss the issue.

 Clarification: The date of the launch has been clarified to indicate the launch was December 11 EST, but December 12 at the launch site in North Korea as well as Greenwich Mean Time (GMT).